awooga83 So they both have draw backs right now and are much of a muchness in what they offer in my view.
This is the main issue, there's such marginal upside.
When we spent pretty big money on Ramsdale, it raised a lot of eyebrows. But when he came into the side, his organisation of the defence and solid mentality clearly expressed themselves, and soon few were in doubt he was an improvement on Leno, despite Leno's good qualities.
It won't be lost on our back four that Arteta's tinkering around with the position behind them without achieving much. And it harms morale when players who seem to be performing are scuttled. We've seen Ramsdale scrapped from the first XI but jaws were open when it looked like Gabriel might be too.
I'm quite unimpressed with Arteta on these points, he seems to have a way to go understanding what works.