All new UCL 24/25: Page 39 - The Arsenal discussion forum and community: One More in the Tolly

All new UCL 24/25

jones

invisibleman18 happened a couple times in the Bundesliga in recent years and was chalked off each time, it's really not a new rule.

jones

Claudius

invisibleman18 I feel like it should have been a retake similar to how it is if the keeper saves and is off the line rather than it being a goal awarded instead. Probably a call we'll never see again like some of the red cards we've had this season.

It is an infringement under Rule 14 if a player taking a penalty strikes the ball twice before another player touches it. In normal time, this results in an indirect free kick. Alvarez can suck on my chocolate salty balls

QuincyAbeyie

Claudius It's not a referee problem, but it is a rule problem. If the keeper steps off the line and saves he gets to try again. If there's something wrong with a scored penalty it should be retaken imo.

Big Willie

Claudius It is an infringement under Rule 14 if a player taking a penalty strikes the ball twice before another player touches it.

Happened to us in comical fashion back in the day. Ask Thierry how he feels about Bobby's attempt to roll the penalty to him.

daredevil

Burnwinter

You can't have the tech and keep everyone in the dark. But then again, I think football revels in controversy. They could easily adopt better technology and refereeing standards if they wanted but even the fucking clubs themselves don't seem all that bothered until it affects them. Semi-automated tech was supposed to come in last season in the PL and we're still waiting and these shitty clubs now want a vote to remove VAR.

More controversy and emotions = more engagement.

JazzG

QuincyAbeyie Agreed and a very good example you've given about the GK.

Claudius

QuincyAbeyie nope
The rules are fine and quite consistent.
1) On the striker hitting the ball twice - The striker is punished for his mistake by having the whole penalty chalked off
2) On the goalie moving off his line and saving - the goalie is punished for his cheating by giving the striker an opportunity to retake. This is nullified if the goalie's cheating is in vain and the striker does indeed score

Btw (1) happens so infrequently - probably less than 1% of all penalties taken that it should not be a priority for changing rules to favour attackers. Name the last time you saw this

Bring Back Kerrea Gilbert

Can't wait to face Real. We will have little pressure on us from outside.

QuincyAbeyie

Claudius The rules are fine and quite consistent.
1) On the striker hitting the ball twice - The striker is punished for his mistake by having the whole penalty chalked off
2) On the goalie moving off his line and saving - the goalie is punished for his cheating by giving the striker an opportunity to retake. This is nullified if the goalie's cheating is in vain and the striker does indeed score

Exactly my point.
The punishment for the GK is not that the penalty is deemed as scored even if the GK cheated.
The punishment for the striker hitting the ball twice is that the penalty is deemed as missed because he cheated.

Consistent would be either
1) that the penalty is deemed as scored if the GK steps off his line and saves, or
3) that the striker hitting the ball twice has to redo his penalty.

Qwiss

JazzG yeah its a lot easier to do that when you have Mbappe, Vini and Bellingham. Wasn't so chill when he had Richarlison, Iwobi and James Rodriguez.

JazzG

Qwiss yeah its a lot easier to do that when you have Mbappe, Vini and Bellingham. Wasn't so chill when he had Richarlison, Iwobi and James Rodriguez.

He played some great football with Everton, in his time at Chelsea as well they played great football. The point is he is more an old school Wenger type where he gives players players more leeway to find their own solutions rather than being coached to within an inch of their life about how how they need to build out and play.

daredevil

Qwiss

Carlo is a perfect example of how managers are defined by the players at their disposal.

You also so see great managers peak and fall and that always without exception correlates with shitter teams and players. We will see if now with Pep unless they bag some stars in the summer.

Claudius

Big Willie yeah, we all remember that. but that was 23 years ago or something. it's not a thing.
i was so annoyed, like what are these idiots doing.
That said, what they were trying is perfectly legal. you just need to ensure you don't touch the ball twice, the recipient is outside the box when you actually kick the ball, and the ball rolls forward.

Big Willie

Claudius yeah, we all remember that. but that was 23 years ago or something. it's not a thing.

Not arguing, just an example I remember of it happening because it happened to us.

Claudius That said, what they were trying is perfectly legal.

Indeed. It's happened a few of times since. Such was the confidence of that team they even came up with it. They could, and probably should, have pulled off that move given their quality. Most teams/players would never have the nerve to even think of trying it.

Claudius

Big Willie if Saka is Pires, he needs his Henry. Will be such a multiplier

Qwiss

JazzG yeah but Wenger also had genius attacking players. Its easier to do when you have that.

USArsenal

I looked at the replay above and i don't actually see where the ball is touched twice. I have not seen the other replays though. Maybe a different one shows something more clearly.

That said, i can remember more than one instance of a 'double kick' penalty being chalked off in the past. IIRC, didn't John Terry have that happen to him once?

Sicario2

USArsenal John Terry’s one was a miss #moscow2008

JazzG

USArsenal I looked at the replay above and i don't actually see where the ball is touched twice. I have not seen the other replays though. Maybe a different one shows something more clearly.

Only on a slow mo replay from certain angles you can just about see it, he touches it and almost straight away kicks the ball, probably like a few milliseconds difference so it is hard to spot

USArsenal

Sicario2

No, i remember that one, but i thought there was a second one (maybe not from Terry). I might be thinking of a different player though. I know i have seen more than one double-touch goal scratched off.

Bring Back Kerrea Gilbert

Yeah I can't see the double contact either.

« Previous Page Next Page »