Which midget midfield playmaker is the daddy!?: Page 3 - The Arsenal discussion community: One More in the Tolly

Which midget midfield playmaker is the daddy!?

Gazza M

Captain wrote:
He's not a cut above thiago and gotze.

Both of them are purer attacking mids, Jack is more of an all round centre mid.

IMO he is better than Thiago, who is - admittedly very good - window dressing in an already superb team. He wouldn't be capable of performing the way Wilshere did against Barca at the Emirates last season. Gotze is closer, we'll see how he fares in europe.

Claudius

All of them are good. More of them should be at Arsenal

Rex

Too true Cali.

Kel Varnsen

thiago, hazard, wilshere and goetze in that order.

Claudius

I think people need to see more of Thiago, Kel. He is under-appreciated on this forum, probably because of Barca hate. Of course, Barca will not sell him given his quality and their preferene for 7 midfielders. He is superb.

lorddulaarsenal

Thiago is awesome - he's another who is better than Gotze. I know its fashionable to like these Dortmund lads but come ooooooon, look at the footy they play

thanks in advance
dools

Kel Varnsen

Caligula wrote:
I think people need to see more of Thiago, Kel. He is under-appreciated on this forum, probably because of Barca hate. Of course, Barca will not sell him given his quality and their preferene for 7 midfielders. He is superb.

he's not proven. by a long shot, but the technique, balance and vision/anticipation is out of this world. some of the stuff he pulls off is ridiculous.

Shady

I think Ganso is overrated. Chucked into that Brazil team far too early.

Thiago is the best of that list imo.

lorddulaarsenal

Looking ahead Id say these youngsters will reach the levels of these players. Not in style necessarily but impact/influence

Wilshere - Roy keane
Hazard - robben
Thiago - iniesta
Neymar - robinho
Shaqiri - hagi
Kagawa - djorkaef
Gotze - Ortega
Ganso - aimer

Kel Varnsen

you think shaqiri will reach the level of hagi?

hagi was unreal. one of the best players i've ever seen.

Big Willie

You really do have something against Goetze don't you mate? Ortega? You think he will flop so sensationally despite being supremely talented like Ortega did?

lorddulaarsenal

Yep, I think he has genuine goal power and the spark to make things happen. Check him out

That said I probably didn't rate hagi as high as you

Big Willie

And Kel, I agree mate. Hagi was fucking awesome especially in those couple of years in the CL/Uefa Cup for Gala. If Shaqiri can reach half that level of technique, vision and shooting ability then he'd be one hell of a player.

lorddulaarsenal

I don't have anything against gotze, I think he's talented but just something's missing.

Ortega had bags of talent. More than gotze that's for sure. I think the kraut will have a better mindset tho and so will end up on a similar level

Big Willie

Ortega was one of the most talented players I'd ever seen but the way he failed to live up to even half his hype was one of the biggest let downs ever. If Goetze is as talented as Ortega he'd be a great player but I though the comparison was more along the lines of impact/influence (which he had next to nothing compared to what he should have been producing) rather than actual ability (which was out of this world).

Captain

Gotze is already better than Ortega ever was and Shaqiri will have done very well to have anybody talking about him while he is playing let alone 10 years later.

lorddulaarsenal

Loyan wrote:
Ortega was one of the most talented players I'd ever seen but the way he failed to live up to even half his hype was one of the biggest let downs ever. If Goetze is as talented as Ortega he'd be a great player but I though the comparison was more along the lines of impact/influence (which he had next to nothing compared to what he should have been producing) rather than actual ability (which was out of this world).

Nailed it. That's what I'm talking about

lorddulaarsenal

Captain wrote:
Gotze is already better than Ortega ever was and Shaqiri will have done very well to have anybody talking about him while he is playing let alone 10 years later.

We'll see. Just like we'll see us finish second this year

Kel Varnsen

i must rate hagi higher than you. he is easily one of the best players in the last 20-30 years for me. him and stoichkov were amazing back in the 90s. underrated both of them.

lorddulaarsenal

Probably. I felt hristo stoichkov was a notch above hagi.

I kinda saw stoichkov at baggio's level whereas I viewed hagi at figo type level if that makes sense

« Previous Page Next Page »