Alan Davies comes out with a lot of weird stuff, always has done, Tayo is usually the only one with a bit of sense but he doesn't have it in him to contradict the others most of the time. Tuesday club is more for light relief than analysis though.
I think Arsecast Extra is the best for analysis personally, probably because arseblog's views generally marry up to my own, but I think gunnerblog does a decent job of playing devils advocate.