If Slot wins the title in his first season it would unfortunately make Artera look very bad.
Official: Mikel Arteta is the new Arsenal manager.
Sicario2 - Tier 1 it would make Slot look good.
- Edited
Claudius and Arteta bad, as all we hear is that he did not fuck up but City are too good, the league is impossible to win etc. It is not. Just that so far, Arteta has not been good enough. And there is no one who can do a better job then Arteta, that was the narative...well in fact, there are plenty
HomeSteak
look. if we go and have a good season overall, and another manager beats us, then massive props to that manager. If we have a completely fucked up season like the Leicester season, then the manager should be held accountable.
I'm just shocked by the number of people giving up and painting these terrible scenarios - and also eager to get stuck in to Arteta who has done nothing but build credit over the last 3 or 4 years. it's bizarre.
HomeSteak This is getting silly now.
Arteta is "not good enough", yet he was good enough to get us to eighty nine points last season. Only one man has bettered that tally in the 140 year history of this football club. If Arteta isn't good enough for you, who is?
Sicario2 - Tier 1 I get what you mean, but Arteta managerial capability is proven beyond doubt by now. He's a top class manager.
If Slot wins the title, it only shows that he's also a top manager and that it's possible to win the title against the machines of City if you don't make mistakes. Arteta has made plenty of tactical or personnel selection issues along the way and has his blind spots, but personally I feel that we made too many mistakes and went a longer route than we should have in the squad building.
- Edited
Every manager will have his faults and blind spots, the question is how does Mikel's faults compare to his peers. I personally think you'll have a hard time finding a better body of work, especially when it comes to squad building.
If there's anything that proves how fine the margins are and how volatile the world of football management is at the top of the game, it's the fact that Man City, managed by a man who many consider the greatest manager of all time won the league last season with over 90 points but are currently sitting in 5th, a point above a team that was battling relegation last season, who are managed by a guy that failed at Spurs.
There are a range of different variables that contribute to whether or not you meet your goals in a season and some are outside the control of a manager. And before anyone suggests it, this doesn't mean Arteta is infallible.
Long story short, let chill the feck out! 
I think you can appraise where we've got to and recognise that improvement and the fact we are in the group at the top of the table and in the mix again. While still critically looking at how do we get to the top and whether Arteta is able to do that.
He's a good manager but not in the same league as those that have won titles. In terms of Arteta's peers I'm comparing him to the managers that have won titles because that is the aspiration and what I feel he's targeting so that's the benchmark. If it is against any manager who has looked fairly good without winning the big honours then that's fine but that's what Tottenham, Rogers Liverpool etc did. If you were at that time praising those clubs for running it close being success fair enough but to me those teams had unique windows where they had the platform to do something and they ultimately failed and those opportunities are rare for most teams so you need to maximise them.
Don Pacifico also proves that we cannot keep having the mentality that we have to wait for 5 more years and 5 more years. Football doesn't stand still for you
- Edited
RocktheCasbah He has won 0 titles, he is not good enough to win it as of now. It's that simple for me.
This year he already fucked it up, he has one more year if you ask me.
We can’t keep using ‘fine margins’ as justification for not winning honours.
I think Slot winning the title will make Artera look bad no doubt about it. What will make Artera look even worse is not winning anything.
Suddenly that league cup quarter final game v Palace is bigger than it should be.
Clrnc
Exactly
Sicario2 - Tier 1 If Slot wins the title in his first season it would unfortunately make Artera look very bad.
Meh. Pool have been lucky so far this season. They haven't reached the levels we've been at past two seasons.
And Liverpool have just beaten City while not even playing at the level we were at when we played City before we got screwed by a red card.
If Liverpool win this season by 9 points from here on in, I'll give them plenty of credit, but as it is they're just appealing front runners which is exactly what you'd expect.
Them winning by less than 9 points would probably be enough for me to credit them tbf.
I'm not disagreeing that he needs to prove something. I fully agree with that. I just find stances like that expressed by @HomeSteak to be out of touch with reality and completely lop-sided in their appraisal of the work Arteta has done.
- Edited
HomeSteak I haven't got the energy for this this week, but as you're not on the Arsenal board, I guess we can safely surmise you won't be asked.
You want to be upset about our start to the season, that's absolutely your right - as it is to ignore the context around the points we have dropped this season. But I'm old enough to remember last year and everyone having kittens because Spurs were ahead of us after 10 games, or whatever it was.
I guess the issue here really is trust - as it always has been. You don't trust the manager - that's fine, again it's your right but I'd ask (again), if not Mikel, who are you going to trust?
QuincyAbeyie Imagine us losing to them by 1 point