I finished season 2 of Treme last night and I can't stop thinking about how good and unique it is. It's especially fascinating to me, and particularly when you consider how both shows premiered around the same time, that one of the things HBO got the most praise for with Game of Thrones was bringing a kind of sociological storytelling to the tv screen, but the show that really pulled it off was Treme.
I think HBO lost their way a little bit when the characters started to dominate their worlds and the narrative instead of evolving in response to the larger change in their surroundings. You can level a lot of criticism against GRRM but the core ambition of aSoIaF was always to tell a story in opposition to the fantasy genre at large, which since Tolkien has been dominated by narratives of individual heroism. It's also the only kind of stories Hollywood knows how to tell, which is why everything in American epic movies is so bland, and why there was such a big perceived shift in Game of Thrones once they ran out of books even if they kept to the big plot points the way they had been outlined by Martin. D&D reverted to telling stories the only way they know, which is about the psychology of individuals, and it didn't help that they were bad at it.
Treme is the
I saw someone suggest that if The Wire is about things falling apart then Treme is about putting them back together again, and I think it has a poetic truth to it.