qs! wrote:As for the keeper with a red card and a penalty how often does that actually happen? And when it does you've removed not a goal scoring opportunity but and almost certain goal. This would give every keeper caught one on one licence to bring down the attacker and take their chances on a penalty.
That is spot on. I don't know why people don't see this. It's the same for outfield players who deny someone an obvious goalscoring opportunity. The red card punishment is in place to avoid a situation where the defending team makes that gamble.