qs! wrote:

Rooney
Roy Keane
John Terry
Teddy Sheringham
Cashley

Gallas and Barton came very, very close.

I'd swap Rooney for Dennis Wise.

Hey Rt New Bruin, Wise isn´t on the effin´ list!!! Rooney it is for you...

Dennis Wise should definitely be on the list. Change the list.

Terry, Wise, Keane, Cashley, van Nistelrooy.
SS Terry stands alone though.

Kevin Davies, Karl Henry, Patrice Evra, John Terry, Van Nistelrooy

Patrice Evra is definitely a good shout actually. I'd drop Roy Keane for him.

Leaves me with Wise, Evra, Terry, Sheringham, Cole.

Evra, Hleb, Robinson(Bolton), Terry, Almunia

All-time is too hard.

Current: Terry, Barton, Evra, Cole, Rooney

Suarez needs to prove himself over a longer period of time!

So, voting done. Opening post updated, but I thought I´d post the results here for those too lazy to go back.

THE TOP 10

Terry 16
Sheringham 11
van Nistelrooy 9
Barton 8
A. Cole 8
G. Neville 7
Rooney 7
Evra 6
Davies 6
Roy Keane 5

For anyone who wonders why a top 5 actually became a top 10 - apparently the only way to get that uber cunt Roy Keane to make the list. Suffice to say I am extremely disappointed in you, my fellow Tollyers, for not giving this scumbag the recognition he deserves.

Did anyone NOT include Terry?

Actually yes, I was surprised to see that quite a few lists did not mention Terry.

No idea what criteria they're applying....
Terry's vileness personified without one single redeeming feature.
Despised from far and wide.
Even people who don't watch football hate him.

Problem with Terry is that it goes beyond the football. A lot of those other guys are cheats and cunts on the field.

Terry is just a bad person. I don't often say that, but someone who parks his Bentley in handicap spots, gives unlawful tours of his workplace for cash, sleeps with his workmate's missus, and allegedly spouts racist remarks is just unsavory.

Roy Keane's too low on that list, he ended a players career!

I agree, such a despicable bastard.

General Mirth wrote:

Roy Keane's too low on that list, he ended a players career!

Thank you TG! Cannot BELIEVE he isn´t higher.

In no particular order

All time

Van Nistelrooy
Gary Neville
Martin Taylor
Terry
Keane

Today
Nasri
Suarez
Rooney
Rio Ferdinand
Joey Barton

Seriously Youn?! We have voting going on for several days. Then, when the voting period is over and dusted and I have presented the results of everyone´s votes, THEN you think it´s a good time to say your piece?! GTFO.