I'm also subscribed to an American podcast called World Football Daily. It has potential to be the best show in the world, but has far too much fat that needs to be trimmed sharpish. They do 90 minutes a day, and bring in people like John Cross, Tim Vickery, Andy Brassell, football players and coaches and others regularly, but 60% of the show is just mindless chatter. If they did a tight 45 minute daily show, it would completely kill it.
Hah, you could say the same about the Tuesday Club. Given that it's an Arsenal only podcast, it's surprising how popular it's become.
I'm on Mugabe media lockdown so I have not listened to Football Weekly in a while but that's very good. Football Ramble has good reviews as well, it's by the same production team that came up with 'It's Up For Grabs Now' but I haven't listened to it myself.
Arsecast is average but he does invite some very good guests sometimes. Worth an occasional listen.
edit: I like Arsenal Fans' Forum too, Tom Watt hosts with a guest journo and listeners phone in to vent. It's surprisingly decent.