Zubimendi looks pretty good defensively. More of a metronome passer, doesn't have Partey's range/creativity I don't think, but still looks a top player to me.
Martin Zubimendi
CPM I wouldn't pretend to be an expert but this video seems to suggest otherwise.
The analysis of Zubimendi seems all wrong to me. I think he's more progressive than any of our midfielders, and I think all the stats are essentially wrong because they don't take the reality of La Real into account.
I at least am not looking at stats. I use match comps to judge potential transfers. There's a good number on Zubimendi, and this is the picture I get: surprisingly robust defensively, very precise tackler, turns beautifully with great ball control, keeps it simple, plays deft and tidy passes, and very good resisting pressure. Lots of short, sideways, and backwards passes. Less adventurous than Partey, but steadier as well. He would be a good complement to Rice and our more dynamic inverted fullbacks.
Much less stiff than I imagined. Two footed as well.
Don Pacifico Reminds me of Mikel Arteta.
Really don't like what I've seen of him if we're bringing him in to be an upgrade on Partey and Jorginho. His touch seems very loose and he holds onto the ball far too long for my liking only to end up passing it wide or backwards.
On the plus side he's very combative and switched on defensively and tackles quite hard, but we have enough of those qualities in Rice and Merino to a certain extent.
Overall I reckon he'll end up being solid yet frustrating player, and end up exacerbating our horseshoe of death pattern and being the target of frustration from the fans.
Big Willie I don't think he's an upgrade per se, he's a replacement for them. Partey has been quite good for us this season, so that's an important bit of squad maintenance. Also, Zubi's fitness record the last few seasons is impressive, he's played a lot of matches. He'll be steady and reliable.
We just need a player like this with Partey and Jorginho done. Watch Real Madrid to see a team without a playmaker. They lack structure.
Horseshoe of death is fine by the way. It’s what we do when we find teams out of formation that is the bigger issue. And that we have to solve with speedy forwards
- Edited
I don't think Zubimendi will be an upgrade either, and it's rather hard for him to be in any case, given how good Partey and Jorginho have been. I do expect a slight drop off but what he does offer is being a ready made replacement who is the best player on the market in his position. I don't think there is anyone better who isn't potential.
Reijnders but he’s not really available.
That would have been an alternative way, and my preferred way, to set the midfield up with Rice moving to DM.
Coombs Jorginho was pretty good when he got a run in the team but barely gets any minutes now.
Don Pacifico massive defensive liability against speedy midfields. But his passing is beautiful
CPM Zubi's fitness record the last few seasons is impressive, he's played a lot of matches.
Touch wood this is true, but if we bring him in and he plays 90% of matches at or near the level of our current starters it'll benefit us. We've had too many campaigns disrupted through the midfield.
I think there's a big disconnect between the perception of Partey and what we have actually seen over the last 2-3 seasons. Partey when he first came in was a monster both defensively and with ball progression/press resistance. However, we really haven't seen that player in the last 2-3 seasons. He's had some good games for sure but I find myself getting more frustrated with his performances over the last 2 seasons than any other player on our squad, barring guys like Sterling. He very rarely shows off his passing range these days and he gets the easy passes wrong far more than any player should. Zubimendi will instantly provide an improvement in ball retention and eliminating stupid mistakes that either make our defenders have to scramble to save him or create a break. I also think Zubimendi will speed up our buildup and play. He doesn't dwell on the ball - cycles it quickly and can get us moving the ball quickly from side to side even if it's not that highlight worthy line splitting pass.
- Edited
samthegooner the stats from comparison matrix don't support your assertion (in terms of passing accuracy).
https://www.squawka.com/en/comparison-matrix/?compare=dVeeG6AtjPSApMbfx9rag
Not sure how they get their stats, but Partey also loses the ball less often, and in general, apart from when it comes to aerial duels, the Ghanaian appears to be superior. I think most are biased against Partey for obvious reasons. He's been solid for us this season.