I disagree, I think he's overrated big time. Most phenomenal shot stoppers are, Shay Given, for example. Casillas' aerial game is a disaster, worse than that even, it's almost comical to watch when he's put under pressure. However, such is the lack of goalkeeping quality over the last ten years, Casillas is definitely right up there in terms of consistent performers. More by default though in my opinion, and I don't think what he has won is proof to the contrary. Gianluigi Buffon is amount twenty times the 'keeper of just about anyone else over the last decade. Now there's a truly brilliant goalkeeper.