Ok, thoughts on Witcher 3 when I'm a few hours into it, then. Should probably say that I'm pretty much only in the beginning yet; in the main story I suppose it is chapter 2, trying to track down Ciri.
I like the game. Fallout and Skyrim are two of my favorite games ever, so naturally I'm going to like this because of the similarities. Having said that, I don't think this game, so far at least, is as good.
It seems to take forever to level up! Wanted to move forward with the story just to realize I'm nowhere near strong enough. So, back to beginning at White Orchard, really delving into the world. Having gone to every damn location on the map, doing mini quests and all, I'm still only at level fucking 4! Feels slow that way. I also don't really like the map with question marks where you are supposed to go; much prefer the blank map where you have to discover shit for yourself.
Still think moving Geralt around is clumsy, but I've got used to it I guess. Especially annoying when you have to be perfectly positioned to interact with an object.
There is no way I'm going to take the time to learn that card game, Gwent. Please tell me I don't have to!
I've collected a fuckload of herbs and shit, but so far I fail to see any real relevance to Alchemy. Except for destroying monster nest that is. 🙂 At this point, that means I don't know what of all the stuff I've collected that is relevant; at this point, that makes the carry weight a bit of a problem. Think this whole section of the game is unnecessarily complicated.
Same is true for using signs. It's a right pain in the ass to keep track of which sign is effective against which creatures. It's complicated enough to keep track of which sword to use...
Why do I have to get to one of those sign posts to fast travel? Annoying! Even more annoying here - why do I have to get off my horse to fast travel?! In fact, it is a bit weak that you can't to any interaction while riding.
Realize this is mostly a rant, but that's not quite fair. Despite these flaws I like the game, but I hope it improves I guess.