How did Robin look?: Page 2 - The Arsenal discussion forum and community: One More in the Tolly

How did Robin look?

goon

http://www.arsenal.com/news/news-archive/-i-can-accommodate-van-persie-and-chamakh-

Basically what Captain said.

Have to say, I think Chamakh and Robin would complement each other brilliantly. You don't really see partnerships like Cole and Yorke or Raul and Morientes anymore but I reckon these two could work as well as any of those.

RonBurgundy

Does anyone realistically think that we'll move Cesc back to central midfield though? I'd like to see it, but it's been quite some time since he's had an extended run there.

daverwr

Whether it will actually happen is one thing, but the thought of Cesc as a deeper lying play maker feeding Van Persie supporting Chamakh (who also gives us a threat from crossing) just seems unstoppable to me. If this were to happen though, one of two things would need to happen in order to accommodate this:

Song would have to drastically improve the defensive side of his game. None of this running into the opponent's box stuff, we'd need him to be a wall at the back. Hopefully he'd notice that with Cesc, Van Persie and Chamakh (and presumably Arshavin and Nasri on the wings) he won't be able to masquerade forward and he shouldn't need to as they are all far better than him offensively.
We'd need to get someone other than Song to take his place and be more protective.

It'll be interesting to see what sort of action Wenger takes.

Ricky1985

I genuinely do think Wenger is considering switching to 4-4-2/4-4-1-1 for certain games. I was really pleased to see firstly, who he picked to play on Tuesday night, and secondly, how exactly he set them out. Setting a team up with only one attacker and the insurance of an extra man in midfield is not needed in the vast majority of our games. It makes no logical sense, and just serves to make our job of breaking down the opposition even harder - we tend to wear them down, rather than open them up.

Clrnc

Didn't Wenger mention that in Arsenal.com already?

Captain

Ricky1985 wrote:
I genuinely do think Wenger is considering switching to 4-4-2/4-4-1-1 for certain games. I was really pleased to see firstly, who he picked to play on Tuesday night, and secondly, how exactly he set them out. Setting a team up with only one attacker and the insurance of an extra man in midfield is not needed in the vast majority of our games. It makes no logical sense, and just serves to make our job of breaking down the opposition even harder - we tend to wear them down, rather than open them up.

I know I keep saying it, but Cesc isn't an extra midfielder now.

Gurgen

I am in favour of this. As Captain said Cesc has been doing a bad Dennis Bergkamp impression for a while now. Why not give his position to a real attacker then and move him back?

Ricky1985

Clrnc wrote:
Didn't Wenger mention that in Arsenal.com already?

Yeah, he did, but I can't seem to find it.

Ricky1985

Captain wrote:
Ricky1985 wrote:
I genuinely do think Wenger is considering switching to 4-4-2/4-4-1-1 for certain games. I was really pleased to see firstly, who he picked to play on Tuesday night, and secondly, how exactly he set them out. Setting a team up with only one attacker and the insurance of an extra man in midfield is not needed in the vast majority of our games. It makes no logical sense, and just serves to make our job of breaking down the opposition even harder - we tend to wear them down, rather than open them up.

I know I keep saying it, but Cesc isn't an extra midfielder now.

Maybe, but he sill drops really deep at times. It seems he's not there as that extra insurance when we need him. I don't doubt that's a fault with the system rather than Cesc being lazy - he can't threaten constantly in the final third and at the same time be there to always help out in defence.

I'd just like to see us keep it simple. 2 attackers when fancy our chances of overrunning our opponents, whether that's one playing off the other or both right up top, and 3 in midfield, 3 actual midfielders who share the defensive task equally, when we need the extra insurance and protection.

Claudius

All this Robin talk...

Robin will just have to find a way to slot in when he returns. I doubt that he can give us a better target man presence than Chamakh, and he can't coordinate an offense better than either Fabregas or Nasri, both of who can also score when playing behind the striker.

He strikes me as an odd man out who will have to fit in at anyone of 3 positions (striker, hole, right attack) when we need to rest players

y va marquer

His introduction proved timely today - he cleared off the line and he laid the ball off to Nasri for his goal.

Just luck? Or experienced player knowing where to be and having the instinct and skill to play the quick lay off?

IBL

He needs a goal to get the taste back, becoming too much of a talented playmaker 😉

« Previous Page